Back
Maintenance of Records
Introduction
When a medico-dental-legal professional comes out of any professional teaching institution,
he faces the risk of medico- legal and socio-economic problems in respect of (a)
the general public, (b) police and (c) the judiciary. So it is necessary to develop
codes of ethics for conduct in practice and maintain records officially and professionally
to protect against commercial, legal and medico-legal litigations in the best interest
of the individual and social justice. It, prima facie, helps any professional and
business practitioner, since any documentary proof is reliable and convincing, socio-economically
and legally.
What the law says
- The Constitutional Law of India: According to Article 51A (H), any citizen of India
has a fundamental duty to develop scientific temper, humanism and a spirit of inquiry
and reform.
- The Dentists Act, I948: Section 17A (I)(II) says of professional conduct: (1) The
council may prescribe standards of professional conducts and etiquette or Code of
Conduct for dentists. (2) Regulations made by the Dental Council under Sub-Section
(1) may specify which violations thereof shall constitute infamous conduct of any
professional respect, i.e., professional misconduct and such provision shall have
effect, notwithstanding anything contrary contained in any other law for the time
being.
Though the Dental Council of India has not prescribed anything specific and recommended
the code of conduct of professional social behaviour. It is logical and practical,
to maintain official, commercial, professional and legal records -- in the best
interests of social justice.
Proper documenting and maintaining of professional records is a professional link
between the past, the present and future. Such professional conduct has moral, medico-
legal value in professional practice and creates confidence and trust between the
medical fraternity, the public at large and the judiciary too.
Benefits of record maintenance
For the purpose of income tax and professional tax:
When a medico-dentist begins a new career, he has to invest a few lakhs of rupees
in establishing a clinic with modern equipment. It is necessary to maintain accounts
in respect of the yearly income and expenditure under Section 44 AA of Income-Tax
Act, 1961, which refers to keeping proper accounts and other documents in a profession
or business Every professional is also bound to file returns under Section 139 of
the Act, though voluntary in nature.
Concept of income
The concept of income includes professional fees, profits and gains, i.e., plus
income, whereas loss of income is no returns or minus income. It is ideal to file
returns even when minus income is declared, as it is observed that a practising
professional is more likely to incur minus income for the first 2-3 years.
Economic budgeting
It means control of savings and expenditure as you earn in professional service,
for personal and professional benefit.
I-T record maintenance
The I-T Act says official records and documentation should be preserved for a minimum
of 8 years. If such records are not maintained, penalties under Section 271(1) are
imposed even though the assessee may file returns in response to a notice under
Section 148 of the I-T Act.
The I-T Act, 1961, is a Central government legislation, while professional tax is
a state legislation. Every professional has to pay yearly professional tax, depending
on the trade, business or profession.
- Personal and professional collection of fees:
Part payment of fees by the patient as well as balance due is recordered on case
papers or sheets and with the help of records, payment due can be recovered from
the patient.
With technological advancement and the advent of the computer, it has become easy
to maintain records. If the payment is not made, the doctor may claim recovery of
professional fees with the help of consumer or civil courts.
- For the purpose of clinico-professional and academic research programmes and policies
in respect of surveys and collection of data
Professionally authenticated record maintenance provides a rationale for self- assessment,
statistical data collection for hypothesis, thesis and theory in respect of research
work and programmes for social betterment. It is also useful in creating new innovations
for post- graduate courses in arts, science, commerce or politics and pharmacy etc.
L.I.C. policies are preserved until maturity or life-long for claims.
- Court and medico-legal purpose
Any doctor may appear in the witness box in court as [a] an ordinary man to state
the facts or events in an F.I.R.; [b] a medico-legal expert can give evidence in
cases such as post-mortem, and a medico-legal or specific medical expert as in compensatory
suits; and [c] as a defence witness, if someone has filed a complaint in litigation
against the doctor.
Legal suits, maintenance of judicial records with regard to three types of judicial
activism is observed
- Consumer Courts: The Consumer Act of India 1986
prescribes minimum 2 years’ time limit from the date of the act or event to solve
disputes; time-barred suits are not entertained by the court.
- Civil Courts: Time limit prescribed by civil law
is normally 3 years from the date of incident, event or fact.
- Criminal Courts: No time limit is fixed or sanctioned
lawfully for filing complaints, offences or crimes in criminal courts within the
jurisdiction of India under the CRPC and IPC. In criminal courts, police’s failure
to produce criminal records as evidence has resulted in acquittals of accused. So
maintenance of criminal court records, accurately and properly, cannot be over emphasised.
The question is how long are professionally related documents like case sheets,
pathological reports and X-ray reports of radiology documents etc to be maintained
or preserved.
No regulation is in force, for practicability, a doctor may maintain records up
to a minimum of 5 years to satisfy consumers and the judiciary as protection against
medical negligence and complications.
These records in question relate to: 1) consent form 2) detection, diagnosis and
follow-up treatment records and (3) recorded allergies of a patient.
- Corroborations and Tallying Forensic Records
Ante-mortem and post-mortem records or findings should be corroborated and tallied
for upgrading and enhancing forensic science and odontology. This aids in solving
legal, medico-legal and social problems including crimes in respect of (a) bite
marks, (b) super- imposition skull technique and (c) establishing identity of persons
living or dead in mass disasters such as airplane crashes or natural calamities.
There is a moral obligation on the doctor and a legal duty, to maintain and preserve
medical, medico-legal and legal documents in the best interests of social justice
and professional justice under Article 51 A(H) of the Constitution and there are
several benefits (under Section 17-A of the Dentists Act, 1948) for those who are
good at record maintenance.