Home About Us Professional StudentPublic Search Contact Us
DentalPracticeAccreditation

Back

Consumer Protection Act

Consumer Protection Act-1986

Statistics show that there has been a 15% rise in number of medicolegal cases as a result of patients using the Consumer Protection Act. It is hence imperative that all dental professionals have an understanding of the law as applicable to dentistry.

Firstly it is important to understand the Rights that the consumer/patients are entitled to

  1. The Right to Safety
  2. The Right to be Informed
  3. The Right to Choose
  4. The Right to be Heard
  5. The Right to Redressal
  6. The Right to Consumer Education
  7. The Right to a Healthy Environment
  8. The Right to Basic Needs

Consumer Dispute Redressel Agencies

Redressal Forums have been established at three different levels:
  • "District Forum" by State Government. At least one in each district, in certain cases District Forum may cover 2 or more district or there may be two or more District Forums in one district.
  • "State Commission" by State Government.
  • "National Commission" (National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission) by Central Government.
Glossary of Terms

Complainant means

Any allegation, in writing made by a complainant that the service hired or availed of or agreed upon to be hired or availed of, by him suffers from deficiency in any respect.

Consumer means

Any "person" who hires or avails of any services for a consideration which has been paid or promised or partly paid and partly promised may include or under any system of deferred payment and includes any beneficiary of such services other then the person who hires or avails of the services for consideration paid or promised, or partly paid and partly promised, or under any system of deferred payment, when such services are availed of with the approval of the first mentioned person.

A person who receives medical treatment in Government or Charitable Hospital, which provides treatment to one and all, free of cost is not a consumer under the Act. A person who receives treatment in a Government or charitable hospital which provides treatment free of cost to some and on consideration to some would be a consumer, even if he has not paid any fees.

In case of death of patient who is a consumer, legal heirs (representatives), of the deceased will be considered as "consumer". If the payment has been made by any person who is not a legal heir of the deceased he too will considered as 'consumer'.

Consideration

Consideration means fees/payment. Fees may have been fully paid in cash or cheques, or undertaking that it will be paid, which is accepted by the doctor/hospital. The fees may have been given partly (as advance) with the understanding that the remaining bill will be paid subsequently. The payment may be done by the patient himself, or by someone else for the patient, e.g. father for his child, husband for wife, any person for someone.

The three words used above (deficiency, person, service) explained under this act are as follows

  • Deficiency means Any fault, imperfection, short coming or inadequacy in the quality, nature and manner of performance which is required to be maintained by or under any law for the time being in force or has been undertaken to be performed by a person in pursuance of a contract or otherwise in relation to any service.
  • Person includes
    1. a firm whether registered or not;
    2. a Hindu undivided family;
    3. a co-operative society;
    4. every other association of persons whether registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860, or not.
  • Service means
    Service of any description which is made available to potential users and includes the provision of facilities in connection with banking, financing, insurance, transport, processing, supply of electrical or other energy, board or lodging or both, housing construction, entertainment, amusement or the purveying of news or other information but does not include the rendering of any service free of charge or under a contract of personal services.
Do's for Dentists
  • Mention your qualifications/ training/ diplomas as regulated by the Indian Medical Degrees Act, 1916 as amended from time experience/ designation on the prescription. Qualifications mean recognized degrees/ to time. Mention of scholarships/ membership/ awards which are not qualifications should be avoided.
  • Always mention date and timing of the consultation.
  • Mention age and sex of the patient.
  • Listen attentively. Look carefully. Ask questions intelligently.
  • If, after completing the examination, the patient/ attendant feels that something has been left out or wants something to be examined, oblige him.
  • Always face the patient. Do not stare. Some patients tolerate very little eye contact. Learn to observe out of the corner of your eyes.
  • In case you have been distracted/ inattentive during the history taking, ask the patient/ attendant to start all over again. He will never mind it. As far as possible consultations should not be interrupted for non-urgent calls.
  • Ask the patient to come back for review the next day, in case you have examined him hurriedly or if you are not sure about the diagnosis/ treatment.
  • Mention “diagnosis under review” until the diagnosis is finally settled.
  • In complicated cases precisely record history of illness and substantial physical findings about the patient on your prescription.
  • If the patient/ attendants are erring on any count (history not reliable, refusing investigations, refusing admission) make a note of it or seek written refusal preferably in local language with proper witness.
  • Mention the condition of patient in specific/objective terms. Avoid vague/ non-specific terminology.
  • Record history of drug allergy.
  • Write names of drugs clearly. Use correct dosages (by revising knowledge periodically), mention clearly method and interval of administration. Here one must use local or sign language. Do not forget writing precautions like Ast./ p.c./ a.c./ locally/ with milk/ h.s.
  • etc. in local language.
  • Mention additional precautions, e.g. food, rest, avoidance of certain drugs, allergens, alcohol, smoking, etc. if indicated.
  • Give instruction to the patient in comprehensible terms, making sure that the patient understands both the instruction and the importance of strictly adhering to them, e.g., while prescribing potent anti-inflammatory drug, if the patient experience any stomach trouble the drug must be stopped and a doctor consulted immediately.
  • Mention likely side-effects and action to be taken if they occur.
  • Remember to advise in writing pathological tests/ radiological tests at specified intervals for certain drugs which require such monitoring. Some examples are: Sodium Valporate, Carbamezapine, Gold Salts, Methotrexate and other immuno-suppressives, Chloramphemicol, etc.
  • Always advise the patient not to suddenly stop taking a drug which is required to be tapered before being stopped. Remember major drug interactions.
  • Specifically mention review, SOS/or follow-up schedule. Mention if patient/ attendant are/ is under effect of alcohol/ drugs. In case a particular drug/equipment is not available, make a note. Prescribe with caution during pregnancy/ lactation.
  • Adjust doses in case of a child/ elderly patient and in renal or hepatic disorders.
  • In case of chronic ailments, mention treatment to be taken immediately in case of an emergency. In case of any deviation from standard care, mention reasons.
  • Mention whether prognosis has been explained. If necessary take a signature of patient/ attendant, after explaining the prognosis in written language local. Mention where the patient should contact in case of your non- availability in case of emergency.
  • If you are not sure what disease a patient has after a through check-up, get a consultation. Develop a list of physicians you trust and respect in each specialties. Nurture your relationship with them and consult them about difficult cases.
  • Whenever referring a patient, provide him with a referring note. In case of emergency/ serious illness, ring up the concerned doctor in the patient’s presence. Show your concern. Always refer to the latest edition of the standard text book of your branch of medicine. Subscribe to at least one standard journal and participate in updates/ conferences every year.
  • Update your knowledge and skill from time to time. If a doctor does not keep pace with recent advances, the quality of care suffers and does not measure upto the standards of reasonable care and skill. (Doctors may become incompetent due to other causes: age, mental illness, addiction to alcohol or drug abuse.)
  • Update not only your own knowledge and skill, but also that of your staff. Update the facilities and equipment according to prevailing current standards in your area.
  • Preferably employ qualified assistants. If not available, impart proper training and skill at your or some appropriate centre and obtain a certificate for the same.
  • Medication to relieve pain especially in post-operative and cancer cases must be carried out carefully.
  • Always obtain a legally valid consent before undertaking surgical/ diagnostic procedure. Learn the difference between “informed persuasion” and “informed consent”. The first is legally wrong, through at times it may be medically correct. (For details on consent, see under “Preventive Steps Against Litigation” in “Medical profession and Consumer Protection Act”, 1994 edition). In case of MTP/ Sterilization, always follow the guidelines issued by the Government of India (See Appendix VI in Medical Profession and Consumer Protection Act, 1994 edition.)
  • While administering an injection/vaccination always check:
    1. Name of the injection (a wrong injection may be given by mistake or oversight);
    2. Expiry date;
    3. Reconfirm the route of administration;
    4. If it is to be diluted, check the dilution factor (1:2, 1:4 etc.);
    5. That a disposable syringe and needle are used. If that is not possible, use syringe and needle after proper sterilization.
    6. In case the patient is agitated/ not co-operating, restrain him properly with 1 or 2 assistants or wait until he calms down. It is not unusual for a broken needle resulting in a claim for compensation;
    7. Confirm that injections are kept at the required temperature;
    8. If required to be reconstituted, check the diluent and whether it has got to be cooled before using.
  • Routinely advise X-rays in injury to bones and joints and related diseases of bones/ joints.
  • Always read reports carefully and interpret the results of tests/ X- rays properly and make a note of it.
  • In all instances of “swab cases” and “instrument cases”, the surgeon in charge has been directly or vicariously held liable for negligence. The surgeon in charge must therefore personally ensure that such mishaps do not occur. The period for the responsibility of the surgeon extends to and includes the post-operative care. He must therefore ensure proper post- operative care to the patient.
  • Always seek proper legal and medical advice before filing reply to the complainant at a consumer court.
Dont's for Dentists
  • Don’t prescribe without examining the patient, even if he is a close friend or relative (Telephone advice is an exception).
  • Never examine a female patient without presence of female nurse/ attendant.
  • Don’t insist on the patient to tell the history of illness or be examined in presence of others. He has right to privacy and confidentiality.
  • Do not permit considerations of religion, nationality, race, party, politics or social standing to intervene between you and your patient.
  • It may not be reasonable for a doctor to assume that what the patient/attendant is saying is truthful when contradicted by the symptoms.
  • Don’t smoke while examining a patient.
  • Don’t examine a patient when you are sick, exhausted, or under influence of alcohol or any intoxicated substance.
  • Don’t be overconfident or look overconfident.
  • Don’t prescribe a drug or indulge in a procedure of which you cannot justify.
  • Don’t prescribe/ administer a drug which is banned, e.g. Analgin.
  • Don’t over-prescribe/ administer: too much of the drug, too large a dose, for too long.
  • Don’t under-prescribe: not prescribing the needed drug, dose is too small, length of treatment is too short.
  • Don’t prescribe multiple drugs. Such prescription may be due to inability to form a correct diagnosis or other causes. Possibilities of drug interactions increase with polypharmacy.
  • Don’t write instructions on a separate slip. Don’t allow substitutions.
  • Don’t adopt experimental method in treatment. If there is some rationale do it only after informed consent.
  • Don’t do anything beyond your level of competence. Competence is defined by your qualification, training and experience.
  • When you are not sure what and why to do. Consult your senior/ specialist/ colleague.
  • Don’t refuse if the patient/ attendants want to leave against medical advice. It is their right. Document this properly.
  • Never avoid a call for help from a nurse on duty at night. In all probability a genuine emergency may be present.
  • Never order an investigation unless the result is likely to help you direct the treatment or make a difference in what you tell a patient.
  • Don’t allow modern diagnostics tests to substitute your clinical judgment. At best, they can only supplement it. Always analyze the cost- benefit ratio before rushing to get these tests done. In case a particular test had false positive or false negative results, explain this to the patient before getting it done.
  • Never label any condition as “functional” until you are certain of the accuracy.
  • Don’t withhold information, however, harsh and difficult, in seriously/ terminally ill patients. It must be conveyed with compassion and gradually, if time permits. The doctors and especially their assistants must train in the art of sensitive communication. It would be wise to take into confidence the family members, close relatives and friends, this would often make the acceptance easier and quicker.
  • Don’t hesitate to extend your condolences and sympathies to the bereaved persons.
  • Don’t divulge secrets you come to know during discharge of your professional duties. There are exceptions to this general principle;
    1. if the patient gives consent;
    2. when it is undesirable on medical grounds to seek a patient’s consent;
    3. the information is required by due legal process;
    4. for the purposes of medical research, after obtaining permission from competent authority.
  • Don’t deny medical care to a patient with HIV infection/ AIDS. Observe all necessary precautions.
  • Don’t inform that the person is infected with HIV unless confirmatory test results are received. Don’t give untrue, misleading or improper reports, documents, etc.
  • Don’t refuse the patient’s right to examine and receive an explanation about your bill regardless of the source of payment; whether or not it is reimbursed by the government or by his employer/ insurance company.
  • Don’t refuse the patient’s right to know about the hospital rules and regulations.
  • Never talk loose about your colleagues, despite intense professional rivalry. Never criticise members of your fraternity. The patient/ attendants may incite you to say/ do something. They may seek your comments on the other doctor’s treatment. There is always a polite way to set aside their comments and queries. Remember if you had seen the case from the start you would have done the same. If your colleague has made an error of judgment regarding diagnosis or treatment, you never know under what circumstances this happened.